Closing Thoughts

As we mentioned at the outset, it's been over a year since we first looked at Dell's XPS M1710. While plenty of things have changed during the past year, our overall impression of the notebook hasn't been altered much. Maximum performance is now better than ever, and the notebook certainly has an eye-catching design. By no means is it an inexpensive notebook, but for those looking to get maximum performance while maintaining mobility Dell's XPS notebook line certainly warrants a closer look.

About the biggest fault that we can find with the XPS M1710 is something that's out of Dell's hands. The GeForce Go 7900 GTX launched over a year ago, and more than six months ago the GeForce Go 7950 GTX improved performance. In the desktop market, however, GeForce 7 series hardware is now old news. If you like to stay abreast of the latest technology news, you probably already know that NVIDIA's going to be launching their mobile GeForce 8000 GPUs very shortly. Unfortunately, as yet there is no successor to the GeForce Go 7950 GTX performance crown. Soon you will be able to get DirectX 10 equipped laptops, but at best we expect the graphics performance to match or slightly surpass that of the GeForce Go 7900 GS - just like the desktop 8600 GTS isn't always faster than the 7900 GS, we expect the mobile equivalents will trade blows up with no clear winner. We still don't have any DirectX 10 games to play, but every day that passes brings such games nearer to release and we would be very hesitant to lay down a lot of money right now on a gaming laptop that won't be able to run those games in all their glory once they become available.

With Dell able to offer an overclocking capable Core 2 Duo laptop, we also have to wonder when Core 2 Quad chips will begin showing up in a mobile form factor. Obviously, we're not going to see 2.93 GHz QX6800 equivalents anytime soon, but some users would certainly be willing to give up a few hundred megahertz in clock speed in order to add more processor cores. Perhaps when Intel begins shipping 45 nm processors we will start to see quad core notebooks. Just like quad core desktops, however, that sort of performance isn't something that many people need right now.

Since the overclocked M1710 that we tested today has been available for a while, it stands to reason that if you didn't want to buy it when it was first launched you probably still aren't interested. You can now get a larger hard drive, Windows Vista, Blu-ray, and who knows what Dell will add in the near future; however, at its core the M1710 remains largely unchanged. It is an attractive, fast, and expensive laptop; the only tests where it didn't come out on the top of our charts are the battery life results, which is a sacrifice that typically has to be made when looking at gaming laptops. If you're in the market for just such a laptop, give the XPS M1710 a look. As usual, however, if you're in no hurry to purchase something right now we would recommend waiting to see what the future holds. Whenever you finally decide it's time to buy, there's certain to be some worthwhile solutions available.

Comparative Performance - Battery Life
Comments Locked

20 Comments

View All Comments

  • Gary Key - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    quote:

    Is it really possible to get thousands of FPS on Supreme Commander? I've never actually played it, but that looks like a typo. If that is correct, what is the difference between getting 500 FPS and 1000 FPS? I thought it was and RTS anyway.


    It is a typo on the chart. The numbers reflected are the total score, not the individual break out on FPS.
  • JarredWalton - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    Fixed. SupCom is a generated score from the perftest map (with an edited benchmark script). Sorry about that.
  • yacoub - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    what?

    Article says:
    "We weren't able to run our latest gaming benchmarks (S.T.A.L.K.E.R. and Supreme Commander) on all of the laptops, so performance results for those games won't be included here."
  • JarredWalton - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    The XPS M1710 OC scaling charts included SupCom and STALKER results. Just not the other laptops (although I might be able to run the benchmarks on a couple laptops still).
  • yacoub - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    I gave up on waiting for laptops to reach reasonable prices. Ordered a nice c2d setup to replace my aging A64 rig and did it for under $425. CPU, RAM, and Mobo. My 7900GT is still enough for now, but when the 8800GTS 640MB hits $350 without rebates I'll probably scoop one of those up too. So still under $800 for a full system upgrade.

    And since I can remote in to my home machine from work and my work machine from home, I really have little need for a laptop, though I do have a company-provided laptop for travel if I really needed to use it. On that flash games (tower defense, etc) are enough to keep me entertained if I'm that desperate to sit in a hotel room(?!). Most likely an mp3 player or a book is all I need in-flight and I'll be out doing things (business or tourist related) when I'm traveling so uber high-end gaming laptops at exorbitant prices just don't really have a use for me, or I'd imagine for most folks.
  • Ender17 - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    The graphs would be a lot easier to read if they were labeled with the actual CPU speed instead of Bin 1, Bin 2...
  • redbone75 - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    Agreed. Just as easy to put 2.33 - 3.16 as it is to do Bin-0 - Bin-5. Actually, you save a character :)
  • JarredWalton - Tuesday, May 8, 2007 - link

    Given that the clock speeds are more of a request than an actual result, I didn't want to use those. I couldn't actually see if throttling was occurring during the game benchmarks, but the scores seem to indicate that the CPU was throttling at the Bin-4 and Bin-5 results on some games.

    The names I used came from discussions with Dell, where they referred to the clock speeds as "Bin + 3", but I used a plus sign instead. Given that the scores are all pretty close on many benchmarks, I didn't think too much about it.
  • Zsuu - Saturday, February 21, 2015 - link

    Good looking Dell <a href="http://www.lapt0p-hu.eoldal.hu/">notebook&...
  • Zsuu - Monday, February 23, 2015 - link

    These laptop is very good http://www.lapt0p-hu.eoldal.hu/

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now