Original Link: https://www.anandtech.com/show/667



Introduction

Five months have passed since NVIDIA introduced their version of a high-end gaming video-card solution, the 64MB GeForce2 GTS. This chip featured a GeForce2 GTS core clocked at 200MHz, 64MB of 166MHz DDR-SDRAM (333MHz effective), and a price tag of just under $400. Not surprisingly, it is basically a souped up version of the less expensive GeForce2 32MB, but the extra 32MB of DDR RAM can help quite a bit in texture-heavy game scenes. The GeForce2 64MB has dominated a good portion of the gaming market, and there is no sign of it slowing down. Competition is present, in the form of 3dfx and ATI, but they have not been able to take the speed crown away from NVIDIA thus far.

Chaintech is well known for their "bang for the buck" products, which usually yield excellent stability and great prices. Like many motherboard manufacturers, Chaintech is based in Taiwan, which has become a small "silicon center"of this industry. Chaintech is a very "easy going" company as they rarely try to deliver a product which differs significantly from the reference design. What do you get when you pair up NVIDIA with a motherboard manufacturer like Chaintech? The Desperado RI-91, a 64MB GeForce2 GTS card.

Chaintech has been making video cards for a few years now, but none have ever received any great attention or recognition. Their first big announcement was with the release of NVIDIA's TNT chip, which ultimately found its place on the Chaintech Desperado RI-30. The trend continued with the release of the Desperado RI-40, based on the NVIDIA TNT2 core, and finally the RI-70, which was powered by the NVIDIA GeForce 256 chip. From there, Chaintech has widened their horizon, and released the RI-A2 in the form of a low-cost GeForce2 MX, then the RI-90 with its 32MB of DDR SGRAM, and now the RI-91 64MB, their current top of the line model. Their slogan for the RI-91 is "GeForce2 Power, Chaintech Price!"

While many competitors are trying to ramp up the value of their flagship card by adding bells and whistles, they're simultaneously increasing the price, which actually lowers the value in the minds of many users. Chaintech, on the other hand, has stuck to the old adage "keep it simple stupid" in order to keep costs down. Lets see what they have to offer this time around.

Features (Courtesy of Chaintech)

Desperado AGP-RI91
Interface AGP 2.0 compliant
4x AGP support / 2x AGP compliant
Chipset
nVIDIA GeForce2 GTS
RAMDAC : 350MHz
Memory 64MB DDR SDRAM ( RI91 )
32MB DDR SDRAM ( RI90 )
Resolution Maximum 2048 x1536  32bit color
Features
  • nVIDIA QuadEngine.
  • 25M Polygons / sec , 800M Pixels / des.
  • 32-bit ARGB rendering with destination alpha.
  • 32-bit Z-buffer / stencil.
  • DVD and HDTV-ready motion compensation for MPEG-2 decoding.
TV-out (Optional )
  • DirectShow , MPEG-1 , MPEG-2 , Indeo
  • NTSC / PAL
  • RCA TV-output / S-Video output jack
Miscellaneous
  • VESA DPMS
  • DDC2 monitor communication
  • Acceleration for Windows 95/98 and Windows NT 4.0 / 2000
  • Software DVD play ( optional )
  • Optional DFP function


The Card

RI-91 comes in the simplest form you can ever dream of, as Chaintech has followed NVIDIA's reference design in every way. There is no reason not to follow NVIDIA's reference design simply due to the fact that the RI-91 does not implement any extraordinary features and NVIDIA's reference designs are quite good.



Click to Enlarge


Click to Enlarge

The fan/heatsink combo is identical to that of the ASUS V7700. The only difference is that the heatsink is painted black. This cooling combo does a good job of dissipating the GPU heat, and the 1.4-Watt fan is virtually silent. The eight 8MB 7ns memory modules are supplied by Hyundai, and are located on the front of the card. This is the main visual difference between most 64MB cards and 32MB cards. All 32MB cards have half of their memory on the back of the PCB. No cooling has been implemented on the memory chips and it is not really needed here.



The Drivers

Chaintech has decided that it is more efficient to use NVIDIA's official drivers, and ditch the idea of releasing their own set of drivers. Many people upgrade to NVIDIA's latest drivers anyway, explaining why Chaintech took this route and why it's not too big of a deal.



Overclocking

The RI-91 was able to remain stable with the GPU clocked at 230MHz, and the memory at 180MHz (360MHz effective). This speed range is where most of the GeForce2 cards land, so there is no disappointment for the RI-91. Overclocking was done via the popular coolbits registry hack, which allowed us to define GPU and memory frequency. This card was a bit picky about the speed at which it ran. At 245/170MHz the card displayed no artifacts in Quake 3, but would lock up after about twenty minutes of timedemo looping. Remember that overclocking is never guaranteed and results will vary among all cards. Visit our GeForce2 GTS Overclocking Guide for more information.



The Test

Windows 98 SE Test System
Hardware
CPU(s)
AMD Athlon 750MHz
Motherboard(s)
ASUS K7A-RM
Memory
128MB PC133 NEC SDRAM (NEC -7E Chips)
Hard Drive
IBM Deskstar 75GXP 35.0GB 7200 RPM Ultra ATA 100
CDROM
DVD Phillips 48X
Video Card(s)

3dfx Voodoo5 5500 AGP 64MB
3dfx Voodoo3 3000 AGP 16MB

ATI Radeon 64MB DDR

Matrox G400 32MB SDR

Chaintech RI-91 GeForce2 GTS 64MB (default clock 200/166)

SUMA Platinum GeForce2 GTS 64MB (default clock - 200/166 DDR)
ASUS V7700/D 32MB DDR (default clock - 200/166 DDR)
MSI StarForce 815 GeForce2 32MB (default clock - 200/166 DDR)
MSI StarForce 816 GeForce MX 32MB (default clock - 175/166 SDR)
ELSA Gladiac MX GeForce 32MB (default clock - 175/166 SDR)
NVIDIA GeForce 64MB (DDR)
NVIDIA GeForce 32MB (SDR)

Ethernet
Software
Operating System
Windows 98 SE
Video Drivers
3dfx Voodoo5 5500 AGP 64MB - final drivers v1.00.01
3dfx Voodoo3 3000 AGP 16MB - final drivers v1.05.01

ATI Radeon 64MB DDR - 4.12_3050

Matrox G400 32MB - 6.04

SUMA Platinum GeForce 2 GTS 64MB - Detonator3 6.18
Chaintech RI-91 GeForce 2 GTS 64MB - Detonator3 6.18
ASUS V7700/D 32MB DDR - Detonator3 6.18r
MSI StarForce 815 GeForce 2 32MB - Detonator3 6.18
MSI StarForce 816 GeForce MX 32MB - Detonator3 6.18
ELSA Gladiac MX GeForce 32MB - Detonator3 6.18
NVIDIA GeForce 64MB - Detonator3 6.18
NVIDIA GeForce 32MB - Detonator3 6.18

Benchmarking Applications
Gaming
idSoftware Quake III Arena demo001.dm3
GT Interactive Unreal Tournament 4.04 AnandTech.dem


OpenGL performance is just as expected. RI-91 performs virtually identical to the SUMA Platinum, which is a 64MB GeForce2 card as well. The GeForce2 32MB cards are slightly faster at low resolutions due to the faster SGRAM chips. A reserve of power is available at virtually all resolutions, and the card manages to spit out just a bit under 45FPS at 1600x1200x32. We can see a constant gain in FPS because Quake 3 balances CPU speed and Video Card fill-rate very well; this also makes it an excellent benchmark.



Direct3D Performance - Unreal Tournament - Athlon 750

This Direct3D benchmark has always portrayed 3dfx cards as speed leaders. The RI-91 starts to show full power of the GeForce2 chip at 1280x1024x32. Playing at 1600x1200x16 suddenly becomes a reality. 50FPS at this resolution is more then most gamers can ask for. Unreal Tournament gains more FPS from CPU speed, rather then the Video Card, which can offset our benchmark scores dramatically.



Overclocked Performance


2D Performance

The RI-91 is heavily targeted towards gamers, but 2D image quality is just as important as smooth 3D gameplay. It's a fact that an average computer user spends more then 75% of his computer time staring at 2D figures, such as web pages and text lines. Its also a well known fact that NVIDIA doesn't have the best "2D record" in the industry, and manufacturers such as Matrox, 3dfx and ATI have always surpassed NVIDIA in this field. However, it should be noted that NVIDIA cannot be blamed directly for this problem because the fault lies in the filters that board manufacturers use, and not with the RAMDAC on the NVIDIA chip. Not surprisingly, the manufacturers with the best 2D image quality happen to produce the boards and the chips themselves. This gives them an advantage, which ultimately results in a better 2D reproduction. Knowing the hard facts we equipped ourselves with a brand new Samsung SyncMaster 955DF display and performed a series of 2D image quality tests.

We chose 3 popular programs as our 2D benchmarks; Adobe Photoshop 5.5, Adobe GoLive 4.0, and Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.5 (Random web pages). The reasoning behind this choice of benchmarking applications is very simple: maximize the variety of 2D models used, which in our case range from simple HTML text, to advanced 2D images. For comparison, we chose the Matrox G400 and the 3dfx Voodoo3 3000.

At 640x480x32 (120Hz) all cards performed very well, although the G400 stood out under Adobe Photoshop as it produced a more saturated picture. The difference becomes more noticeable as we bump the resolution to 1024x768x32 (100Hz), in which case the G400 was a whole step ahead of the RI-91 in every test. At 1152x864x32 (85Hz) the RI-91 met its end, and produced a non-impressive picture that came nowhere near the G400. Very high resolutions such as 1280x1024x32 (75Hz) and 1600x1200x32 (60Hz) showed the most difference in which the RI-91 produced a series of tiny blurry horizontal lines, while the G400 was still on top of all benchmarks. Voodoo3 was somewhat better then the RI-91, but still nowhere near the G400.



Final Words

Chaintech is good at keeping company traditions. Their tradition of producing "plain gaming cards" has not changed. It soon becomes quite obvious that Chaintech didn't shoot for the top, and this card is targeted towards those looking for a GeForce2 GTS at a good price. Chaintech has done a great job in cutting cost, without cutting corners. They have brought the card price down without sacrificing valuable performance, stability, or reliability.

How it Rates

Please note that this card is rated against similar GeForce2 64MB cards. To learn more about our rating system, please click here

AnandTech Video Card Rating
Rating (x/10)
Performance

Raw speed is key to success of this card. Performance is virtually identical to other 64MB GeForce2 GTS?s out there.

5.0
Price

At around $300, the RI-91 is a bit cheaper than most 64MB GeForce2 GTS cards currently available.

6.0
Drivers

Its not surprising that Chaintech has not included a set of their own drivers, or any useful applications. The bundle is straight to the point; NVIDIA Detonator drivers, DirectX 7,and a BIOS flashing utility.

4.0
Features

This is as plain as it gets. This card was never meant for multimedia use. The card will work quite well for people who don?t demand VIVO options.

4.5
Retail Availability

You would have to run around the net to find this card. Only a selected group of online retailers will sell the card.

4.0
Documentation & Software Bundle

We received a very simple booklet from Chaintech, no manuals and no extra software. The booklet outlines all of the basic features, but won?t help you further.

4.5
Overall Rating
5.0

Note: The Overall Rating is not an average of all of the categories

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now